Supreme Court Dismisses Third Major Challenge to Affordable Care Act

AHA Special Bulletin
June 17, 2021

See AHA’s media statement on the ruling; watch for an analysis this afternoon from Sean Marotta, who authored AHA’s friend-of-the-court brief in this case

The United States Supreme Court this morning rejected the third major challenge to the Affordable Care Act, holding in a 7-2 decision that the challengers did not have “standing,” or the legal right to challenge the portions of the ACA they alleged were unconstitutional.

The plaintiffs contended that without a penalty to back up the ACA’s individual mandate, the mandate could no longer be justified under Congress’ taxing power and that the newly unconstitutional mandate could not be separated from the rest of the ACA. However, the Court held that the individual plaintiffs challenging the law did not suffer an injury traceable to the allegedly unconstitutional individual mandate because the mandate did not force them to do anything; a statute that tells patients to buy insurance but does not include a consequence for noncompliance does not harm anyone.

The Court likewise held that the states challenging the ACA did not suffer an injury traceable to the allegedly unconstitutional individual mandate because their claimed “pocketbook” losses in providing minimum essential coverage came not from the mandate, but from portions of the ACA that the states did not challenge. The ruling said that because neither the individual plaintiffs nor the states had standing, the Court rejected the challenge in total, leaving the ACA unscathed.

Justice Stephen Breyer wrote the Court’s opinion. Justices Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch dissented.

AHA TAKE

In a statement shared with the media today, AHA President and CEO Rick Pollack said, “The more than 30 million Americans who secured health insurance under the Affordable Care Act can again breathe a sigh of relief. But our work is far from over. We need to redouble our efforts to close coverage gaps and make care affordable and accessible for everyone, all while continuing to fight COVID-19 and encouraging more Americans to get vaccinated. The AHA is eager to partner with Congress and the Biden administration to make sure all Americans can achieve their highest potential for health.”

Watch for a blog with more analysis in AHA Today this afternoon from AHA outside counsel Sean Marotta, a partner at Hogan Lovells, who authored AHA’s friend-of-the-court brief in this case.

FURTHER QUESTIONS

If you have questions, please contact AHA at 800-424-4301.

Related Resources

Fact Sheets
It is imperative that Congress invest in America’s hospitals and health systems to ensure that the nation’s health care needs can be met today and into the…
Letter/Comment
The American Hospital Association (AHA) would like to share hospital and health system priorities that would benefit patients and communities around the…
Advancing Health Podcast
Public
Dr. Trestman and Dr. Hochman reflect on the far-reaching effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on the mental health and well-being of health care professionals,…
Case Studies
Public
St. Peter’s Health, a non-profit health system in Helena, Montana, serves over 97,000 residents across five counties. In 2017, the rise of perinatal mood and…
Advancing Health Podcast
Public
Communities of color, who over the past year have been disproportionately affected by the COVID-19 pandemic, also experienced emotional distress exacerbated by…
Letter/Comment
Public
The Honorable Chiquita Brooks-LaSure Administrator Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Hubert H. Humphrey Building 200 Independence Avenue, S.W., Room…